You've got to admit, this place has charm. They take the pirate schtick VERY seriously and there is lots of kooky eye candy to distract you. And while eating at this place is an experience in itself, the food is just eh. It's you're typical bland seafood fare. They have pretty decent wedding soup, I'll give them that. But it's just very boring baked seafood in butter, with no seasoning. The menu is enormous though and I've hardly begun to sample it, so maybe you'll have better luck. It certainly wasn't bad, it was just kinda so-so. The problem was, the bill just mounted up very quickly and I spent more than I would have expected, especially given the quality of the food. Will I return? I don't know. It's a fun place to take visitors to the area because it's such an interesting spot, but I'm still kind of on the fence with the food.