It isn't trendy. It isn't fancy. The chef isn't famous. It is just plain good.
I like Red Devil. It is one of those places where ordering way too much pizza on purpose in order to enjoy it again for lunch the next day is perfectly normal and A-OK. The service is consistently friendly, attentive, and happy to offer menu suggestions.
I can't comment on their wide variety of main dishes (which all look appetizing), because I can never tear myself away from the pizza. What goes great with that pizza? The Antipasto salad is fantastic - loaded with meats, cheese and even my favorite artichoke hearts. A small is more than ample for two people to share. Save some of that Italian dressing (presented on the side) to use as a dipping sauce for your pizza crust. Instant breadsticks! Speaking of pizza, Red Devil's graces a thin yet doughy crust with tangy sauce and generous evenly-distributed toppings. My favorite, pepperoni and mushroom, tastes wonderful when re-heated for lunch the next day too!
Go, sit in one of the bar's padded booths. Enjoy an adult beverage or two (there are typically drink specials of some kind or another) and order a pizza big enough to take some home. :)