I would say I have slightly mixed feelings about this place. It seemed like it had so much potential. The staff was very friendly, the location was nice, the setup inside worked well. They have wine on tap which is always fun, although I might just have a slight hangover :)
The food on the menu looked amazing as described but the two dishes I tried I found to be just OK - maybe it was fluke and the rest is awesome which is what optimistic me wants to think but I can't give this place more than 3 because I thought the food was average.
The No-Meat Meatball Melt was pretty good but it comes on a relatively boring bun, I would say this could use a bit of umph to it.
The Cassoulet too I found to just be average. I wish I could say more but for a smallish bowl of beans, hard to find sausage and small piece of duck it just wasn't great. There are almost too many flavours in there you can't even appreciate the duck.
To conclude, I would return but not in a hurry.