Visited: 6-14-2015
3.25 - 3.5 stars would be more accurate.
Everything was pretty solidly average, sometimes slightly above-average. Nothing awful, but nothing was outstanding, either. I'd have no problem dining here again, but probably wouldn't go out of my way to make it happen.
We ordered a salad to share as an appetizer, and our server split it evenly between two plates before bringing it to the table (without us asking her to); that was a nice touch. However, I just realized (after perusing their online menu to refresh my memory regarding the details of the dishes we had) that we didn't receive the "Tribeca Ovens baguette and chive & honey butter" with the salad. The only other misstep was pesto missing from my sandwich (though I didn't realize it was missing until about halfway through, since there was fresh basil on the sandwich). My husband liked his shrimp po' boy with potato salad.