I've only ever gotten the grilled cheese and soup here- I've been twice but I just HAD to get it a second time because it was SO GOOD the first time! But if I'm being honest, the grilled cheese alone is enough to deserve 5 stars. The sandwich, the tomato bisque, and the fries were all exceptional. The atmosphere was nice, but then again I wasn't really paying much attention to anything other than the emotional connection I was having with my otherworldly grilled cheese sandwich. The host and wait staff has also been very pleasant and attentive both times. Also a plus that they're so welcoming to doggies (wish I could bring my dogs out in public without experiencing Non-stop Barkfest 2k16).