2.5 stars. I had the "hungry like a wolf." I specified that I wanted my steak cooked "medium" and it was very well done (completely brown - see picture), which was disappointing after seeing so many pictures of perfectly cooked steak on Yelp! They may have been willing to try again, but I don't like wasting food (especially meat).
I was also expecting a more substantial salad - again based on reviews of people touting the size of the small. Overall the salad was lacking in everything: ingredients, flavor (except for the dressing, I could really only taste the overdone steak), and impression. I don't know if I would give them another shot - if I need a last minute "healthier" lunch alternative and I'm in the area, I may try again.
I am also surprised by the spike in their prices - if you look at some of the menu pics (from just last year), most of their small salads were $5, some $6 - now they are $8 and $9. I get the fluctuating market, but damn.