I eat here at least once a month and I haven't been disappointed. We mostly order take out -- one pizza and one pasta -- and share among two people. I've tried most of the menu and recommend that you get out of your comfort zone and try something new. They do a great job of creating oven baked simple yet eclectic pizzas. Portions are large for two people, but probably small for three people, nevertheless, they are fast and the food is always reliable.
I've dined in restaurant with a group of friends and with family about half a dozen times. It's a nice ambiance, the restaurant smells great, and they are pretty good at accommodating picky eaters. I don't really have a bad thing to say about Al Dente Trattoria.