I think Nostrano is by far the best fine dining place I have tried in Madison. The waitresses were friendly and even the bartender was nice to greet you too (which I find it rare since you have waitresses to do that).
The food is amazing and while I definitely prefer more choices due to my pickiness, I can see why this limited menu choice works so great in their favor. The risotto was packed with flavor despite how simple it sounds. I enjoyed the cocktails they had too.