Decided to check this place out since this seafood-in-a-bag concept is becoming popular in the area. I also wanted to see how they redid the old Winking Lizard. It's nautical themed, but not really in your face. We (party of two) went on a Thursday night and were seated right away. There is quite a bit of seating and there were only 2 other occupied tables around 8:30p.
They have a small bar that only offers beers and wine. That was a little disappointing. We ordered the Seafood Lovers combo and it came with calamari. We got it seasoned with "Shake sauce" which is Lemon Pepper, Cajun and Garlic together and we asked for it to be medium spicy. We could have went extra spicy. It wasn't enough for somebody who really enjoys spicy foods. The food came out quickly. Within 5 minutes or so. The calamari was really good, my SO liked it more than I did. I didn't care for the long calamari pieces as opposed to the round bits that I'm used to. The seafood was more than enough to share. 2 large crab legs, a ton of crawfish, mussels, and shrimp. It also had corn and potatoes. We really enjoyed getting to the bottom for all the seasoning. We were also provided with gloves and bibs but had to ask our server for forks and crab crackers. The process was super messy, but enjoyable. I wish that we had been offered wet naps at the end. I'm not sure if they don't have them or if they need to be requested.
Overall, it was a cool way to spend an evening. Getting to eat with your hands without looking like a complete barbarian. I got to teach my SO how to eat crawdads ahead of our trip to New Orleans too. As others have mentioned, you can get to the ice cream shop through the restaurant. I had intended to check it out but there were a ton of people in there and I was impatient lol. Another time.