Sadly, it looks like everyone who posted here had a horrible experience with their $5 Steak & Eggs.
My group was lured to the cafe by their $8 Steak & Shrimp, which we unanimously found delicious. The steak (at medium-rare) was nearly perfect, and the shrimp was excellent.
While I've never their $5 Steak & Eggs, I will definitely go back for lunchtime $8 Steak & Shrimp. It definitely beats a $40 buffet.
------
In addition, their service was fast. We hinted that we needed to be somewhere, and they picked up that we were in a rush. We got our meals within 10 minutes. That's good service.