Can't go wrong with most anything on the menu - yeah, even the falafel and smoked polish (I suggest Milo's mustard sauce) are great. Not a huge fan of the portobello sandwich nor the ribs. The staff is great. Beer selection is regularly changing, not that I drink beer that often but its fun to go in a get the dog bone flight to try new things.
The late night menu is also awesome. They make, in house some of them, different kinds of hot dogs and other tasty crazy tid bits that may only hang around for a week or so. One of my faves was a smoked tomato soup where they smoked all the ingredients, it was meatless and awesome!
They also host special dinner throughout the year. I've attended a few and never been disappointed.