They have Joust, so that alone is enough to warrant five stars for me!
I used to frequent Barcade when I lived in Brooklyn, and I actually like the setup of Abari much better - there's no awkward space in the middle and with the rotation of games, it always feels like there's more to explore.
The staff, especially the owner, are friendly and passionate about the games. Great selection of craft beers on tap and cheap PBR.
It gets pretty crowded on Friday/Saturday nights, I'd recommend getting there early or spending a rainy weeknight relaxing on their living room couch.