We stayed at the Concourse because of it's convenient location, and because my husband convinced me that it was nicer than the other places we'd stayed in Madison.
The bar was nice, and the complimentary drink coupons made it even nicer. The staff was friendly enough and the bed was comfy. It's walking distance from State Street, which is convenient for those of us who like to imbibe a bit.
The bathroom was gross. For what we paid, I would hope for a bathroom that had been updated in the last 30 years. It wasn't "historical" or "antique". It was old, the fixtures were cheap and it was generally disgusting.
It's not worth the money, but the choices in Madison are limited.