I've only had a few things here, but what I come back for is their store-made pasta sauce. I get the spicy one and it's delicious paired with pastas or meatballs I make at home. I prefer homemade sauces vs. the canned ones you get at grocery stores. Their sauce comes in a large mason jar and sells for $7 so it's not super cheap, but good value compared to the grocery stores.
I've tried their pastries - in particular the cannolis - and I wasn't a fan. They were dry and tasted a bit stale to be honest.
I've also tried a slice of pizza - while greasy, it was delicious nonetheless and only $1.50. I hear their sandwiches are quite good though so will go back to try those someday.