It was unclear from the description that this is more of a store than a dessert counter location. If you go at the wrong time, they could easily be out of whatever it is you want. We showed up for dessert at 8:30 on a Thursday and there was almost nothing left. We ended up going with the crack pie ice cream (which is basically butterscotch soft serve with cornflakes on it in a little paper cup) and it actually cost $7. It tasted nothing like the crack pie and was very over priced. Super disappointing, definitely call ahead if there's something in particular that you're hoping to try.