Happened to show up on a Monday night and I'm not going to lie, I was unimpressed.
I'm not sure why this place has so many great reviews. Maybe I'm spoiled because I live downtown Toronto where North of Brooklyn makes a beautiful margherita pizza (for $9 more, side note: it's also a larger sized pizza). And California Sandwiches is up the street and has a mean veal sandwich with tomato sauce that is to die for.
Air circulation could be improved, it was a little warm. The food was not great. It was definitely made fresh to order, but could be greatly improved. Margherita pizza was a flat out disappointment. Not a proper margherita pizza. The chicken sandwich I got was sickly sweet and I'm not sure why. My boyfriend and his dad got lucky ordering pasta.
The person that greeted us was incredibly nice, but I think the fact that there was only 4 people in the restaurant and then 2 were in athletic wear...made a not so great impression. The "cafeteria-style" ordering threw me off. I've been to a few places that had a similar structure of billing, but was done a lot better. I had a lot higher expectations and everything about this place was extremely underwhelming.