I do like this place quite a bit, but it's a bit over hyped. Everyone raves about the food, but the food is really just OK. Maybe it's what I've ordered, but it doesn't seem anything special to me. In fact, a couple things I've had there are a bit funny tasting. The brie and veggie sandwich, for example, tastes kind of ....off. The service is iffy too, especially since they moved to their new location. It can be hard to flag down your waitstaff to order or get your bill.
Not to be totally negative though. They have a great beer selection. The new space is cozy and inviting. The decor has all these awesome old maps that i'm totally a sucker for. It really is a fun place, but just not the "best pub in the city" and it doesnt have the "best food of any pub in the city." Let's not go overboard here.