Let's all agree that this place is expensive. Let's also agree that they do a few food dishes right, and the rest are just so-so (and not worth the $$). But I keep coming back here.
It's just a whole lot of fun. The high ceilings, the classic decor, the great location, the busy/noisy atmosphere, the beer selection...
Even in the menu's copy there's a playfulness that shows they just want you to have a good time. Just a great place to hang out with friends/coworkers.
Tips: Belgian Frites (amazing and great value) + wings. I brought a date here once. I forgot her name. But I clearly remember the frites.
4 stars out of 5.
Jimmy's Yelp Ratings Scale for Food:
[*] Disappointing. Just...no.
[**] Not very good. Will not return.
[***] It is what it is. Go enough times and you'll break even on quality.
[****] My go-to place. Rarely disappoints.
[*****] Everything on menu is good. Every time.