I live in Little Italy and walked by this place a BILLION times. After hearing so many positive reviews, my curiousity caught up with me and I finally made my way inside for some balls (Get your mind out of the gutter!)
I ordered the Rodfather, and homemade lemon soda. Truthfully the soda was kinda "meh", and it didn't really blow me away. The sandwich however was quite good. Now when you think of a sandwich, you picture yourself holding it with both hands as you bite into it. Not an option with the Rodfather! The meatballs were huge, and I'm afraid I'd have worn most of the sandwich if I didn't use a knife and fork. Not an issue for me what-so-ever. I proceeded to eat this delicious concoction with content, and enjoyed every bite of it. The meat itself was perfectly textured and seasoned. The sauce was very good, however I wish there was more of it, and the bread, fresh albeit soggy from all the yummy goodness plopped on it.
If you're looking for a great "sandwich" or crave something different, I'd highly recommend this spot. Just be prepared to loosen your belt a notch or two afterwards! ;)