My first visit here was great! I came as part of a large group and ordered a half-order of spaghetti with blush sauce and OMG is was so tasty and the portion size was just right. I also had a caprese salad, which had a lovely balsamic reduction and large pieces of mozzarella. The only reason I give it 4 stars is because of the interior, it's quite outdated and the chairs are not comfortable.
Since our visit, we've ordered the takeout New York style pizza and it's delicious, so close to real NY pizza, even our picky kids love it!