First of all, I dine extensively for work while entertaining clients. I frequent Proseco and 312 in Chicago.
So for Crop's prices and claims, I feel they were not up to par with entree originality and quality for the price ($130 for 2 entrees, 1 soup, 1 salad and a bottle of $45 cab). I ordered the waldorf salad to start. It's thinly sliced in ribbons (carrots and apples) which made it unruly to eat. I ordered the squash bisque which was average (I've had better at Melt) and while my lamb was juicy (it's a fatty meat), it was cooked through - well done. The cous cous was great, however. My dining mate had the salmon which was great (the sauce made it).
It's a beautiful location but the noise level at Crop is like eating on the floor of the New York stock exchange.
Overall, underwhelmed --- If I do go back it will be to have a glass of wine at the bar with some mussels.... maybe.