What's not to like?
Excellent sauce, delicious thicker crust baked perfectly. Excellent, generous toppings and the most delicious sauce. No denying that the pizza is wonderful. And when you pick up the box, it has heft, so you're definitely getting a nice size pizza.
Price? A little high unless you use a coupon or get in on a daily deal, then it's within reason.
I have stopped ordering from other places that are so expensive on topping prices that you have to tap into your IRA to pay. Gionino's has kept topping prices reasonable without sacrificing on quality. Kudos for that.
Chicken and jojo's are very good too.
Very nice people working there. Always welcoming, polite and friendly.
Gionino's in Tallmadge definitely is my favorite spot for quality pizza and fried chicken.
Cheers