Update - I had such a great experience here initially that I brought my family for Christmas Eve. Very rude service. I get that it's rough to work on the holidays but my family wasn't getting the dry humor and felt a bit ignored early on. Portions are very underwhelming. I was ultimately a bit embarrassed to have suggested here. The kind blonde waiter who made our guac was wonderful and redeemed the experience a bit by being super friendly to everyone, but he was not our main waiter. This place is too pricey to have bad experiences over bad attitudes. :(
We love this place! We ended up at The Mission after celebrating a birthday dinner at Postino (which never disappoints!) and actually wished we had started here once we saw the menu. The service was outstanding, so fun and friendly. Beautiful ambience. Can't wait to come back here for a meal!