My family and I took a weekend trip to Madison from Chicago. It also happened to be a Saturday when the Badgers were playing basketball and hockey games. After spending the day at the basketball game and walking around Madison we were ready for a nice dinner.
We waited about an hour for a table of 6. We arrived around 6 so waited until 7. The one annoying thing is that you can't put your name in and walk away so we waited outside for a bit. When we were seated we ordered our food.
We got the cheese curds with the different dipping sauces for an appetizer. They were amazing! I got the Mac and Cheese...I mean when in Wisconsin. It was decent, but I've had better.
One of the highlights of our trip to The Old Fashioned besides the location and atmosphere was the draft root beer. I'm sure I'll visit again the next time I visit Madison, hopefully over the summer when it's warm.