I'd heard really great things about their downtown location from my sister, so my expectations were pretty high for this place. I was excited that it was a build your own burger bar with a veggie burger option, since I'm a vegetarian.
I love barbecue anything, and it's rare that I get to experience good BBQ as a non-meat eater. I decided to get the veggie burger with a BBQ rub, farmhouse cheddar, BBQ sauce, and grilled onions. Unfortunately I was pretty disappointed in the flavor and texture of the burger, I guess I should have guessed that their BBQ wasn't that popular because none of their suggested burgers combinations featured barbecue sauce. I also ordered a s'mores (non-alcoholic) shake that, to me, was just okay.
My boyfriend got an actual burger that had similar rub/toppings and was also pretty disappointed.
I think next time I go I will get an already-recommended combo of toppings. I think Burgatory has potential to be delicious, my expectations were just a little too high for my first time.