- 1 star for the marbled rye bread, soft and delicious
- 1 star for the vanilla egg cream soda, just like grandma liked
- 1 star for a really good dill pickle
- 1 star for sitting outside with the fun fake NY city streets and people watching
- 1 millions stars for the NY Sky High sandwich: fresh sliced pastrami, corned beef, and turkey with coleslaw and thousand-island on rye OMG YUM