This place SEEMS like it would be good, however the food was below average and the service sub par.
My wife's food was lukewarm and lacked flavour. The cheese inside her cheese enchiladas tasted more like paneer. My $16 chicken tacos weren't good at all either. We ordered the ceviche as an appetizer and it came without any chips. Can I get a WTF?? Just a single lone Saltine. There wasn't a lot of fish in it either.
On top of all this, it was incredibly expensive. $100 with tip for two (with 3 drinks).
http://i.imgur.com/WFsYH.jpg
If you went to Playa Cabana first, you're gonna have a bad time.
TL;DR: Go to Playa Cabana instead.