This place gets a solid 2.5. I've been here a few times and the experience can be very unpredictable. The first time I dined here was brunch. They served me undercooked potatoes. This is the worst thing you can do to someone who truly enjoys their breakfast spuds. It was months ago and I still remember it. I recall our server at the time was quick to whisk it away and apologize. I appreciated that.
The most recent experience was for Monday night trivia, which is actually a good time. I ordered the Lemon Salt n Pepper wings ($14) and couple others ordered the chicken pot pie (comes recommended by the server $16) - both I would recommend. The pot pie was supposed to come with mashed potato except they were out. It's 8pm and you're out of mashed potatoes? What is it with this place and potatoes?!
The kicker came at the end when my friends ordered a second pitcher of the house lager. My friend took a sip and thought it tasted off so we all took a sip of it to confirm before he told the server. Believe me it was definitely off. We conveyed this to our server and she took it away. She came back to us a bit later and said "we'll take this off your bill, but the manager and another bartender tasted it and they say it tastes fine". Why oh why did you have to tell us that??
First of all, we never asked for their opinions. There's four people, no wait, four paying customers who say this particular pitcher of lager tastes strange. Secondly, it's not like we drank most of it and then told you there was something wrong with it. Lastly, congrats to you that two employees think it tastes like how it's supposed to and we're wrong.
I think their house beer is pretty good so the one bad pitcher of beer is absolutely not a reflection of the quality. However, the servers ability to handle this situation was very disappointing.