IT WAS OK.
Went here with a couple of girlfriends on a Friday night. Luckily we made a reservation a week before so our table was guaranteed. We came in 1/2 hr earlier and we only had to wait for 5 minutes to get our table set up. Not a bad start.
As soon as we settled in, we couldn't help but notice the loudness inside the restaurant. IT WAS VERY LOUD that we had to yell out our words to have a proper conversation. At the end of the night, one of the girls lost her voice. Uh oh.
We shared a pitcher of white sangria. It was alright. It's a pretty small pitcher and it didn't come with any fruits in it. Wait, it did. A few diced apples. SCORE. That costed us $20.
I ordered grilled chicken and baked brie sandwich with a side of fries. The sandwich was pretty good, I liked the sweet and savory blend. However, it's too oily. The fries were ok, tasted like McCain's fries. One friend ordered the chicken tacos. She said Joey's tacos were better :p The other friend ordered the chicken cajun sandwich. She didn't say much about her food so I guess it's neither here nor there.
Didn't order any appy or dessert, though I really wanted to try the s'mores! Perhaps another time...
Overall, it was an ok experience. Our waitress was ok, neither attentive nor ignorant (maybe a little snobbish? I got that vibe from her...) I'm going to try Joey's first before coming back to Earl's so I can make a proper comparison :)