I'm not a native of Madison nor went to school here, but every time I visit I NEED to go here.
Best breakfast I've ever had. You can't go wrong with any omelette selection and their pastries are out of this world. Specifically, the chocolate croissants and cinnamon rolls. Bacon= Delicious. Chocolate Chip Pancakes = Heaven
Be aware that you are most likely going to have to share a table, but it's all part of the experience.