My friend and I had such high hopes when we went in. 4 stars on yelp, thoughts of melty sandwich goodness. How can anyone say no to that? Overall, it was just the food we were unimpressed by. The restaurant is a large sports bar like restaurant with a bunch of crazy decorations. Fun! We went in right before the lunch rush and were seated promptly. Service was ok. The menu has a lot of choices and if you feel like you can't eat a whole sandwich, you can get half. Prices are very reasonable.
I got the Lake Erie monster (fried fish with slaw and jalapeƱo tarter sauce) with fries and slaw. My friend got the Kindergarten (basically a plain grilled cheese) with fries and the buffalo chicken chowder. The fish in my Lake Erie was lackluster, sort of like the fried fish fillets from the frozen section. If the bread was normal sized, it would look pretty plain. The slaw helped cut through the heaviness of the meal, though it was plain tasting. My friend like his buffalo chicken chowder. Very cute that they used goldfish crackers. However, he didn't even like his Kindergarten, which is just a basic grilled cheese.
Overall, it wasn't the melty goodness we were expecting. The bread is very hard and large and the cheese seems to be premelted onto the bread, so it wasn't even gooey. The biggest offender though? The fries sucked! How can you mess up on fries? They looked so good but tasted so stale. The fact that the food wasn't good even before the lunch rush makes me not want to come here again.