I was so surprised that I loved this place! With the name, I expected a cheesy theme restaurant. But it actually was not! We were seated on the bar side, and the wait staff was very good. Could have definitely used a bit less lighting, it was very bright at our table, but honestly that was my only minor complaint. I had a Reuben wrap that was excellent! All the good flavors and ingredients of a Reuben, but without all of the mess! The waffle fries were very crispy as well. As an app we had fried pickle spears that were just delicious. Rum Runners had a smaller menu, but everything on it was something I would get. Will definitely be returning here.