I've never really been a fan of the Barley House since going there one afternoon for lunch. The food really isn't that good for the money you pay especially knowing the other restaurants I could have gone to instead.
The afternoon I did eat there, all I got was the pizza. It was greasy and oily in a bad way. Trust me, I love the pepperoni / cheese oily goodness that can be a sign of great pizza but the one at Barley House didn't fare well with me and my wife. This surprises me because I do like the pizza at Harry Buffalo (same owners) but for some reason they refuse to link the two. This could have changed since I went there last so let's just keep our fingers crossed.
Recently I was there for a Browns game party bus from the east side. We had reserved the back bar area which was great, however there was only one female bartender pouring free beers / drinks to about 60 drunks. This did not fare well and we ended up about 5 deep waiting for drinks. We decided that tipping her $20 right off the bat would help, and it did, drinks started flowing our way each time we peeked our heads toward the bar. Let that be a lesson to you I guess....ha.
The entire bar was packed on a Sunday for game day so if that's your cup of tea then I highly recommend heading over there for some football but if a relaxing Sunday with good food and chilly brews is your preference, then let me suggest your local suburban sports bar where the bartenders know your name.