This place has a serious split personality as evident by the reviews. I have experienced both good and bad sides and unfortunately, their lack of consistency makes me think twice about going back.
I have been to Sweet Melissa's about half a dozen times and those experiences have been 50/50 good and bad. I have gone and experienced everything from decent service and very tasty food to horrible service and sub-par food.
What's frustrates me most is that I have ordered the same thing on three separate occasions and had a different result ranging from delicious to mediocre each time. How can this occur?
Their menu is nice with with a good range of choices, but who wants to flip a coin when they go out to eat wondering if they are going to get Jekyll or Hyde? Pull it together Sweet Melissa's and then I'll go back. You could be great. Until then, I think I will try a place where I know what I will get.