I think I just found the best sub shop in town.
Captain Bill's has been around forever. I even remember this place as a kid, though I never went here. No idea why.
The place is a very small subshop that houses about six or so small tables and covered wall to wall are pictures of people who have been there from way back in the early 80s. I recognized many people from the pics and it was a pretty cool idea.
I ordered myself a salami, pepperoni and cheese sub (baked) along with some italian dressing. I thought "Well I'll get an 8" because the full is just too big." I destroyed that thing in a matter of a few minutes. I could have easily done a 10" sub. The bread was so soft and crunchy in just the right toasted way. The meat and veggies inside were just perfect and the italian dressing made it a sweet finish.
I can't wait to go back! This place is the best!