OK - updating review. I discovered soon after I wrote my initial review that MM is strictly an eat-in restaurant for us. I ordered a medium pizza & meatball app to go. He said 25 minutes. 25 minutes later I arrive and he checks on my meal. "3 more minutes in the oven," he says. Ok, great. Pizza will be piping hot. We live 5 minutes away. By the time I got home, the meatballs were hard as rocks and inedible. The pizza was lukewarm to cool. Was definitely NOT right out of the oven and in fact seemed to have been sitting there awhile.
The crust and pizza is so stellar at Mellow Mushroom. The steam inside the pizza box ruins the crust and turns the pizza rubbery.
I still give eating in 5 stars....2 for takeout. Solid 3 overall.