It has been a long time since I've been to a Cornish Pasty Co... I'd mostly been to the Tempe location near ASU when I was working in that area. They have expanded a lot and the menu has many more items than in the "old days."
While getting your food seems to take a bit longer than I remember, the quality remains high. I have never had anything here that I did not like, but I've also never had the lamb or salmon, so...
For first timers, I'd say you can't go wrong with the Oggie, Cajun Chicken, or anything on the dessert menu, but you're best served picking something that has a filling combination that sounds good to you. They even have a whole section of vegetarian pasties now!
Can't decide on ONE that you like? The pasties come out cut in half, which makes sharing awfully easy as long as you can get a friend to split with you.
Their beer list probably has something for everyone as well.