I've been to Bonfyre two times. The design of the restaurant is gorgeous. My first visit, I brought out-of-town guests expecting a pleasant ambiance and delicious food. Both visits, the food tasted like frozen lean cuisine. It was barely edible. Both times I ordered a pasta dish. My guests ordered meat and said it was also devoid of appreciable flavor.
The redeeming factors were the service and the decor.
Ultimately, I was disappointed to have taken my out-of-town guests to Bonfyre when there are so many great restaurants in the Madison area.