The Captain's Boil is an experience. This is why I'm rating it a 4. If you've never shelled your own lobster or cleaned a shrimp, this is something you need to try.
We went as a group and ordered a combination of shrimp, lobster and crawfish. The lobster was by far the best thing we ordered, and was on special at $20 for a full lobster. The shrimp were tasty, however after sitting in a hot bag for too long, they do become over cooked. For a lot of work and very little meat, the crawfish were not worth what we paid for them. We ended our meal with complimentary ice cream. The table agreed that it was possibly the best mango ice cream we've ever had.
I highly recommend getting the Captain's Boil seasoning on your choice of seafood. I got the mild version and it was the perfect balance of garlic, spice and seasoning.