I have more conflicted thoughts on the Dane, than Norman Bates does on a good day.
Point:
-Dane sponsors a lot of leagues/clubs around town offering free pitchers and discounts.
-Always has a very sizable selection of beers with reasonable tags.
-Very uniquely Madison and dares to be different.
-Large space that on most weekdays can accommodate larger groups.
-Garden downstairs remained a secret from me for years, but it rocks.
-Nice downtown location...(*personality changing* though by Madison standards, difficult parking)
Counterpoint:
-Has a lot of down nights, with annoying frat tossers and overcrowding.
-The food is better than regular bar food but I wouldn't come here specifically to eat (as many unwisely do)
-The beers overall tend to be more on the hoppy side (may or may not be your deal) I like hops but have never once remarked 'I love that beer!'
-Busier hours, spottier bar service especially upstairs.
It's worth an occasional visit but it's not the go-to destination like the Terrace or even a more local/casual bar. Like a famous club the original Dane is sorta played out to residents. If you can handle the drive and less idyllic surroundings, I prefer the Ale Asylum for beer and comfort.