It was alright. While staying t New York New York we have walked by this place many times but never stopped in part because there was never a line and also because sometimes it smelled too fishy. We finally decided to give it a try. The fish was crisp and not anymore greasy than anywhere else. The service was a little show. I cannot say I would go back but I cant say for sure I would not if I got desperate for a fried fish fix. However I am not a huge fish eater and if it even begins to smell fishy its not for me. I will say what we had did not taste that way.