Maybe slightly higher than a 3 star - but not a four star.
I have been here about 5 times. It is a small pizzaria with a New York Theme. The staff is very friendly. The prices are very reasnoable. It was cool because we ordered a "pitcher" of root beer - pitchers of root beer take me back to the pizzaria days of my youth...
They have decent food. My major hang up with this place is the pizza is soggy in the middle part. You can't fold it properly or even lift up. The pizza tastes good but it is just to soggy - almost wet in the center. There are 2 ways to eat it; you have to fold the point end towards the crust or you are reduced to eating the pizza with a fork!!!
Also, Ordered a cannoli. It was very good. They might even make the shell homemade (if this can be confirmed I would rate this a 4). It was the right color and it wasn't perfectly round like the a factory made shell. I told the waitress - "Leave the gun - take the cannoli." She had no idea what I was talking about.
So - It isn't the best in town, but it will cure a pizza fix if you are in the northwest part of town.