I'll settle at 4 stars.
It's my wife's favorite - she absolutely loves this pizza.
I think it's just OK - not a huge fan of the crust or cheese, but the toppings are very good.
So 5* for her and 3* for me.
The service is absolutely fantastic though. First time they called to check up on our order we were a little thrown off - now we expect it.
You can tell they care about their product and it's definitely worth checking out. Everyone has different tastes so if you are like my wife you'll love the pizza and at worst you'll still have a great experience.