Sugar & Spice has ruined my ice cream palette. Meaning, it is so good that in all seriousness, no ice cream can compare anymore. After trying it for the first time in December, ever since I have not been able to find better ice cream. You can taste the fresh ingredients in the perfectly homemade ice cream. They have such a large selection of flavors it is always hard to decide which flavor. The setting inside the store is such a great atmosphere taking you back in time. Everyone working in the store is friendly and helpful answering every question about flavors, sundaes, etc. I highly recommend. It's worth the drive and especially with the holidays coming up, they have a great candy supply store right next door.
Personal favorite: Chocolate Chip Doreo. Yes, I mean it is oreo ice cream AND cookie dough. Doesn't ever get better than that.