This was my third time, and I just keeping chasing the high that was my first time at Arrogant Butcher. Looking like I will never get the quality that I got the first go around. I ordered the scallop dish and the first time it was amazing. One of the best all around dishes I had ever had. The second visit I ordered them, and they were raw in the middle. Fluke perhaps? Last night I gave it another go and the vegetables were undercooked and the scallops were chewy. Sad, really. I seek out restaurants with consistent food quality. This is another to add to the list of unpredictable, sub par meals.
Plus side: Waitress was friendly and relatively fast. The Pinot noir wine offered is one of my favorite bottles ever. The ice water is good, and thankfully doesn't have a weird taste that is commonly found in restaurant water.
Was hoping that the third time would be the charm but sadly, I don't think I will go back for a fourth.