Heaps of ice cream and other pieces of sweet goodness, mounted on a belgian waffle are always a must at Demetres. I've been coming here since I was 12 and it's just such a great place to get fat.
I usually get the rusty pelican... some chocolate and nutella stuff and maybe some brownies... chocolate sauce... caramel... who knows?! but it's amazeballsssssss. I do have to mention though, that I HATE whipped cream and maraschino cherries, so I always do without it when I go to Demetres (let the hate comments begin for my hate-relationship with whipped cream)
Service here isn't great, but I'm usually a happy camper when I'm eating sweets, so I can't really complain and the prices are great, so I'm still not going to complain. I did decide to venture outside of the Rusty Pelican one time and it wasn't a pleasurable experience. I had something with tiramisu ice cream at one point and it was nasty... and one time I had something with peanut ice cream... and that was even worse. If you're ever wondering what "dry" ice cream tastes and feels like... try the peanut ice cream... it was awful lol
Anywhos... I found my favorites and they never fail. Still a really great place to go, and they just renovated their outdated decor! :D