So, it's a local business; that's cool.
I like finding out "stories" behind these one-off type places, so I asked the lady behind the counter to tell me about the ice cream. Apparently, it has a higher butterfat content than most ice creams and isn't made onsite, but by some folks in a nearby town or something. (Forgive the fuzzy memory, just wasn't too impressed with that).
Anyway, I got a chocolate shake and it was all right. Certainly not worth the 6.50 I paid for what looked like 12 oz. or so, but live and learn and say it was better than it was to save face!
The atmosphere is kinda hipstery, but it's nice. I may give it another try, but I'm not looking forward to it or anything.