Always a fun atmosphere, warm chic bar with live music which is usually the location for our meals last night we opted for the dining room. My friend and I started with the shrimp cocktail and decided to pay for for a few extra shrimp since that was the only appetizer we were having (seafood is always fresh) I always get the petite filet 8oz which is plenty for me. I am extremely picky with how my meat is prepared and they have always done it perfectly medium rare, I always order medium rare more on the rare side and usually at restaurants it comes medium rare, at City Hall they nail it for me right between rare and medium rare. My friend is clearly more of a meat eater ordered the 22oz Bone in Ribeye he killed it all 22oz's of it. Our sides consisted of creamed spinach (always one of my favorites) we usually get lobster mac and cheese (to die for) tonight we got the scalloped potatoes because my friend wanted something different. In general scalloped potatoes are not my favorite but this creamy rich concoction was by far the best scalloped potatoes I have ever had. We were in a food coma at the point that AMEX sent over "Mastro's" signature butter cake for booking the reservation through American Express. Sweetness overload with the butter cake and iced cream but always amazing!