I only experienced Valentino's a handful of times, but I was never disappointed. Working summers at CWRU made for some great lunch breaks and after work dinners here. I loved nothing more than to sip an Aranciata while chowing down on a meatball pizza (which is not on the menu but they will make it for you if you ask). Every pizza I tried was fresh, flavorful, and made-to-order.
Delicious, and always hits the spot after a drink or two at Lounge Leo down the street.