I once loved Montauk. I've come here since they've opened. A new GM took over the helm recently (a few months now). I have sincerely given him the benefit of the doubt in spite of the decline in service since he's started. However, all good things must come to an end. Today, I was served chicken wings that were spoiled. I took one bite and immediately tasted that sour taste that you typically smell when you open a package of chicken that you waited too long to make. They had to have smelled it; the spoiled taste was strong. I sent it back and told the server that they need to take care of our meal. The manager came over, apologized, told us they would take care of it, and asked us if we wanted anything else. We ordered deviled eggs and a salad and they were good as usual. They took the spoiled chicken off of our tab and charged us for everything else. I'm not sure if they think that we should be appreciative of them taking the spoiled chicken off of our tab, but I paid it and left. Spoiled chicken is a sure way to get food poisoning. My guess, they don't care. I will take my business elsewhere. I'm thinking Farm & Craft.